This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy for more information.
Valentine’s Day isn’t complete without enjoying a ton of sweets, so it would be crazy to skip these delicious homemade Valentine’s cookie recipes!
Whether you’re with friends, family, or that special someone, celebrating with an indulgent dessert is a must.
Sure, you can always enjoy store-bought candies and chocolates, but why not elevate the Valentine’s Day gift and create their favorite dessert from scratch?
22 Romantic Valentine’s Day Cookies
This is where homemade cookies come along!
Your partner will appreciate a big batch of cookies made with love, symbolizing the effort you’re willing to put in and the appreciation you have for them.
Plus, who doesn’t like a soft, chewy, freshly baked cookie after a romantic Valentine’s Day dinner like these recipes here?
When crafting your sweet gift, you don’t need to stick to the usual chocolate chip cookies.
There are many Valentine’s Day-themed cookies to surprise your lover with.
We list down 20+ cookie recipes to try with different flavors, adorable aesthetics, and even healthy ingredients!
Pin this image and save it to your Pinterest Valentine’s Day board!
1. Valentine’s Day Brownie Cookie
Recipe by Raising Generation Nourished
Chocolate is known to inflame desire and romance, which is why many turn to Valentine’s Day brownies as their go-to gifts.
But if your partner is obsessed with cookies, combine the best of both worlds with these gluten-free Valentine’s Day brownie cookies!
2. Valentine’s Day Cookie Cake Pop
Recipe by 360 Family Nutrition
Easy to eat and pop in your mouth, these cookie cake pops are a great gift or dessert idea with cute pure white decor and a chocolate drizzle to set the mood.
They are also suitable if you’re short on time because they only take 20ish minutes to make!
3. Valentine’s Day Cupcake Cookie
Recipe by Cutefetti
This is another interesting combination that merges a Valentine’s Day cupcake with a cute cookie on top of buttercream frosting.
It’s two desserts in one for your partner to indulge in!
4. Low-Carb Valentine’s Day Cookie
Recipe by Low Carb Inspirations
If your partner’s on a keto diet, there’s no need to skip out on the best part of dinner! Cater to your lover’s diet with this low-carb Valentine’s Day dessert.
Going the extra mile will improve your relationship (and your overall health).
5. Valentine’s Day Sandwich Cookies
Recipe by The Decorated Cookie
These may look scarily complicated but not to worry, as they aren’t that difficult to bake. You won’t burn down your kitchen or burn what you baked!
Rather, you’ll end up with mouthwatering and packed sandwich cookies your partner will love you more for.
6. Red Velvet Valentine Cookie
Recipe by Dessert for Two
Red is the color of bold love and desire, and these cookies will indeed show your burning passion.
Top them with a lovely white chocolate heart to add more aesthetic and sweetness to your dessert.
7. Dark Chocolate Strawberry Cookies
Recipe by Domestically Blissful
Go the fancier route with these dark chocolate strawberry cookies.
Dark chocolate is a “love” drug and strawberry is the symbol of Venus, the goddess of love.
It makes sense to combine both into an indulgent cookie for Hearts Day!
8. Strawberry Chocolate Chip Cookies
Recipe by Sally’s Baking Addiction
Strawberries are such a romantic gift and you can incorporate them into your homemade cookies!
Infuse strawberry flavors into your cookies and you get pink cookies with slightly tangy flavors that go so well with the sweet chocolate chips.
9. Strawberry Shortbread Cookies
Recipe by Emma Duckworth Bakes
We add more strawberry-based cookie recipes because, well, who doesn’t like strawberries?
These sweet and slightly tangy shortbread cookies will perfectly match a cup of coffee after your romantic dinner.
10. Strawberry and Cream Cookies
Recipe by Baker by Nature
Strawberries and cream, a match made in heaven. These simple sugar cookies are so easy to make but will leave your partner impressed.
The secret is white chocolate chips and freeze-dried strawberries for that added flavor and pretty appearance.
11. Decorated Valentine’s Day Sugar Cookie
Recipe by Mom Loves Baking
Are you looking for that perfectly decorated Valentine’s Day sugar cookie?
Whether you’re baking it for the kids at school or your significant other, we guarantee everyone will fall in love with this sugar cookie recipe!
12. Copycat Crumbl Valentine’s Cookie Recipe
Recipe by Love From The Oven
Does your partner adore Crumbl cookies?
Well, you can fool them and tell them it’s a real deal. Oh, trust us – your lover will believe you.
Whether it’s Valentine’s Day, a special person’s birthday, or the Christmas holiday, you can’t go wrong with this copycat Crumbl cookie recipe!
13. Big Chocolate M&M Valentine’s Day Cookies
Recipe by The Salty Marshmallow
Go big or go home!
You don’t need to go all out and spend hours in the kitchen preparing these cookies, though.
Your partner will squeal in delight with these palm-sized cookies filled with pink and red M&M’s!
14. Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies with Chocolate
Recipe by Sugar Salt Magic
Thumbprint cookies give the simple sugar cookies a unique twist with raspberry ganache as the jewel center.
You’ll leave the middle part for last because of its creamy, sweet, naturally sweet, and slightly acidic flavor profile.
15. M&M Cheesecake Cookie Bars
Recipe by What’s Gaby Cooking
No one ever made the strict rule that cookies have to be round!
These cookie bars feature three layers of sweet goodness.
There’s the indulgent cookie dough, creamy cheesecake filling, and M&M’s sprinkled for aesthetic and extra sweetness.
16. Chocolate Shortbread Heart Cookies
Recipe by Two Peas & Their Pod
These chocolate shortbread heart cookies have all the sweet flavors anyone will love.
They are also very indulgent, with each cookie dipped in melted chocolate and pink sprinkles for even more chocolatey goodness!
17. Peanut Butter Valentine’s Cookie
Recipe by Tastes Better from Scratch
Peanut butter and chocolate are like two peas in a pod.
The creamy nuttiness from peanut butter goes fantastically with rich and creamy chocolates.
Combine them in a soft, chewy cookie, and your partner will have a new guilty pleasure!
18. Strawberry Cream Cheese Breakfast Pastries
Recipe by Cooking Classy
These cookies look perfect on a gift box or plate but don’t worry, as they are easy to make!
These are heart-shaped puff pastry cookies are filled with creamy cream cheese and strawberry jam that your lover won’t get enough of.
19. Valentine’s Day Heart Sugar Cookies
Recipe by Ahead of Thyme
Looking for another sugar cookie recipe for this Valentine’s Day?
Go nuts, my dear – put your love in your words AND bake with these creative sugar cookies.
No need for stellar piping skills when writing words you’d like to tell your partner, like “I LOVE YOU” or “UR CUTE!”
These taste as amazing as they look but only take an hour to complete!
20. 3-Ingredient Valentine’s No-Bake Cookies
Recipe by Dizzy Busy & Hungry
Recipe by Dizzy Busy & Hungry
No time or can’t buy ingredients in the grocery?
This recipe only uses 3 simple ingredients and you’ll get love-themed goodies perfect to gift.
Adding to that, these are no-bake cookies that will only take 10 minutes of your time!
21. Triple Chocolate Cookies
Recipe The Pioneer Woman
What’s better than chocolate cookies?
TRIPLE chocolate cookies with a glass of milk to down it all!
Your partner will be high on a sugar rush and you’ll be high off the huge smile you’ll see as they finish what you baked.
22. Valentine’s Crinkle Cookies
Recipe by Balancing Motherhood
These are strawberry chocolate crinkle cookies that are slightly crispy on the outside but soft and chewy inside (with a ‘lil heart in the center!).
Serve them fresh and watch as all these cookies disappear into your partner’s stomach!
Leave a Reply